Group work stages, leader tasks and confidentiality for the ASWB exam
Groups move through predictable stages, most often taught as Tuckman's forming, storming, norming, performing and adjourning. The leader's job changes at each stage, and one rule holds throughout: the social worker can ask members to keep confidences but cannot guarantee that they will.
Last updated · Published by Certloom Learning · Independent; not affiliated with ASWB.
How this page was made: written by Certloom Learning with AI assistance from the primary sources listed at the end, then checked against them on the date shown. Not reviewed by a licensed social worker.
Is group work on the ASWB exam?
Yes. Both outlines list group work techniques and approaches, including developing and managing group processes and cohesion, and the dynamics of relationships, including groups.
The guidebook's Masters sample about a dual-diagnosis treatment group using role play keys on assessing each member's capacity to take part before using the technique. Confidentiality limits, which matter a great deal in groups, are a separate statement under Values and Ethics.
Five: forming, storming, norming, performing and adjourning. The five-stage version is usually cited to Tuckman and Jensen's 1977 paper, Stages of Small Group Development Revisited.
The American Group Psychotherapy Association's practice guidelines, as summarized in StatPearls, pair each Tuckman stage with a phase name used in group therapy and describe what happens in each.
Stage
Parallel phase
What members do
Leader focus
Forming
Preaffiliation
Look to the leader for guidance; anxious about each other and about whether the group will help
Education, pointing out what members share, building trust
Storming
Power and control
Resent slow progress and dependence on the leader; challenge the leader's authority
Stay calm, manage resistance and countertransference, keep members on their goals
Norming
Intimacy
Connect and see the value of working together; cohesion is high
Shift from leading to facilitating; balance support and confrontation
Performing
Differentiation
Use individual differences to make personal changes; comfortable with interdependence
Not described separately in the summary
Adjourning
Separation
Face the loss of the group; may regress, idealize or devalue the group
Help members see their changes and process the ending; some groups use a closing ritual
What does the leader do in the beginning, middle and end?
SAMHSA's group therapy TIP uses three phases. In the beginning, the leader handles introductions, reviews the group agreement, sets a safe tone and healthy norms, and starts the work. In the middle, members interact, get feedback and rethink their behavior. The end phase is about closure.
Early on, the leader is more active and supportive than later, keeps emotional expression manageable, and does not allow confrontation, because a new group cannot yet withstand much conflict. In the middle phase the leader balances content (what is said) and process (how members interact), and pays attention to nonverbal cues.
Phases apply to each member, too. In an open, revolving group, every new member enters the beginning phase when they join, and the leader helps old members welcome them.
The American Group Psychotherapy Association's guidelines, summarized in StatPearls, list evidence-based therapeutic factors. Cohesiveness, the emotional bond among members, is treated as a core mechanism and tracks closely with improvement.
Factor
What it means
Universality
Members see that others share similar feelings and problems
Instillation of hope
Seeing others succeed makes members hopeful for themselves
Imparting information
Members learn from the leader and from each other
Altruism
Helping others improves members' self-image
Imitative behavior
Members learn by watching others work on their problems
Interpersonal learning
Members get feedback and try new ways of relating
Corrective experience
Family dynamics replay in the group in a way that changes the member's view
The same review describes Wilfred Bion's three basic assumptions that pull a group off its work: dependency on the leader as a rescuer, fight or flight, and pairing, the hope that two members will solve things for everyone. It also warns about scapegoating, which can harm members who lack the resources to cope with it.
Groups also differ by membership. Closed groups keep the same members from start to finish and process endings together; open groups admit new members as others leave.
The social worker is bound by confidentiality, but other members are not bound the same way, so the worker must seek an agreement and tell members it cannot be guaranteed. NASW Code 1.07(f) asks social workers in family, couples or group counseling to seek agreement on each person's right to confidentiality and duty to protect what others share, and to tell participants they cannot guarantee everyone will honor it. Standard 1.07(g) adds informing clients of the agency's policy on disclosing information among the parties.
StatPearls adds practical steps: discuss confidentiality in preparation as part of informed consent, have each member sign a confidentiality agreement, set clear consequences for breaking it, tell young members what may be shared with parents, and keep each member's notes free of other members' identifying details.
SAMHSA notes that members may still talk about the themes of the group and their own disclosures, and that legal duties such as reporting child or elder abuse still apply. For more, see confidentiality and the duty to warn.
These worked examples are original and fictional. They are not ASWB questions.
Example 1: the third session
In the third session of a closed parenting group, two members complain that "nothing is happening" and ask why the social worker does not just tell them what to do. Another says the last group she attended was better run.
What should the social worker do NEXT?
Best answer: Stay calm, acknowledge the frustration openly and invite the group to talk about what they want from the sessions. Challenges to the leader are typical of storming, and handling them well often pulls the group together.
Switching to lectures gives in to dependence on the leader and stalls development.
Asking the critical member to leave treats a normal stage as misconduct.
Ignoring the comments leaves the conflict unaddressed.
Example 2: the first meeting
Before a new grief support group begins, a member asks the social worker to promise that nothing said in the room will ever be repeated outside it.
What is the BEST response?
Best answer: Explain the group's confidentiality agreement and the worker's own duties, ask all members to commit to it, and say plainly that the worker cannot guarantee every member will keep it.
Promising complete confidentiality is a guarantee the worker cannot keep.
Telling the member that nothing personal should be shared in a group defeats the purpose of the group.
Deferring the question to a later session leaves members to decide what to share without the facts they need.
Can you try practice questions on this topic?
Yes. Here are 2 original fictional items from CaseReason's free bank. Choose an action and a reason, then reveal the feedback or read every explanation.
AI wrote the items and a separate AI review checked them; a licensed social worker has not reviewed them yet. They are not ASWB exam questions.
Sample 1 · Masters · Values and Ethics
Before a peer-support group begins, a participant asks the worker to guarantee that no member will repeat anything outside the room. What is the best response?
The requested guarantee concerns the behavior of other group members.
Read every explanation
Decisive fact → next action
The requested guarantee concerns the behavior of other group members.
Action alternatives
Guarantee secrecy because members signed in. Attendance cannot ensure other members’ conduct.
Best supported action · Explain confidentiality duties, seek a group privacy agreement, and explain that members’ compliance cannot be guaranteed. This sets useful expectations without an unsupported promise.
Skip ground rules because privacy is entirely members’ responsibility. The worker still needs to discuss confidentiality and seek agreement.
Why the reasons differ
A privacy agreement can reduce risk without guaranteeing compliance. The response combines a protective step with an honest limit.
A signature ensures future privacy behavior. Signing does not make a guarantee defensible.
Uncertainty removes the worker’s responsibility to discuss privacy. The limit should be explained as part of that discussion.
Item masters-s08
Sample 2 · Clinical · Values and Ethics
Before a voluntary counseling group begins, a participant asks whether other members can be guaranteed to keep stories private. What should the facilitator say?
The question asks for a guarantee about other group members' actions.
Read every explanation
Decisive fact → next action
The question asks for a guarantee about other group members' actions.
Action alternatives
Say nothing can be done about privacy, so no agreement is useful. The absence of a guarantee does not remove the value of clear agreements and discussion.
Best supported action · Explain the confidentiality agreement and its limits, including that members' compliance cannot be guaranteed. The facilitator can seek shared commitments while accurately explaining the limit of their control.
Guarantee privacy because each member will sign the group agreement. A signature cannot guarantee the future behavior of other participants.
Why the reasons differ
A confidentiality agreement supports expectations without giving control over every member. Correct: explain both the commitment and the limitation.
Signed agreements make every possible disclosure preventable. The facilitator cannot promise that outcome.
The facilitator's own confidentiality duty guarantees members' behavior. The facilitator's duty does not determine what every participant will do.
Item clinical-s12
What else do test-takers ask?
Is storming a sign the group is failing?
No. Conflict with the leader and between members is expected in this stage, and working through it builds cohesion.
Do all groups go through every stage?
Not neatly. SAMHSA notes that one or two sessions of a revolving group can cover all three phases for one member, while a long-term group may spend several sessions just beginning.
Can a group member be required to keep confidentiality?
Members can sign an agreement, and the group can set consequences, but the social worker cannot guarantee compliance.
From the sources below, read on 2026-11-14 unless a line says otherwise. Rules, fees and board requirements change, so confirm anything you rely on with the body that sets it.
This page summarises these sources in our own words, with short quotes marked. CaseReason is an independent study app and is not affiliated with ASWB, NASW or any licensing board.